We have reviewed security assessments of mining operations conducted by consultants who spent a single day on site.
One day. On an operation that runs several shifts, spans multiple access points, employs hundreds of people, and sits inside a regulatory environment that takes months to understand properly.
We have also reviewed assessments from individuals with impressive academic credentials and almost no practical field experience. One recommended an electric fence around a facility teeming with wildlife. The client’s internal audit lead deemed that an essential requirement from their insurer’s “chosen expert”. We, the external security auditors, were considerably less enthusiastic.
The result in every case is the same: a document that reflects the consultant’s available time and experience more than the client’s actual risk profile.
This is not a criticism of individual practitioners (ok, maybe it is of some). It is the reality of a system with no common framework, no consistent scoring, and no basis for meaningful comparison. One assessor’s “adequate” is another’s “critical deficiency” because the system asks each of them to invent their own methodology from scratch.
And this is the data the insurance industry is underwriting against. Premium calibration built on foundations that vary wildly in quality and reliability — and nobody in the room knows which assessment is which.
The sector deserves a structured, standardised methodology. Complementing the individual SME model with a consistent framework — applied with the same rigour across every site, every jurisdiction, every operator — is not a new idea. It is simply one the industry has been slow to act on.
At Armetor, it is the foundation of everything we do.


